Table of Contents
- 1. Why etendue is conserved (or increases) in the first place?
- 2. I want the mathematical derivation
-
- 2.0.1. 1. Define the ray phase space
- 2.0.2. 2. Use canonical ray variables
- 2.0.3. 3. Relate this canonical volume to \(n^2 \cos\theta\, dA\, d\Omega\)
- 2.0.4. 4. Why Hamiltonian flow preserves it
- 2.0.5. 5. Simple 1D paraxial version
- 2.0.6. 6. Why it can increase but not decrease in practice
- 2.0.7. Final compact statement
-
- 3.
1. Why etendue is conserved (or increases) in the first place?
Étendue is basically “how spread out” light is in area × angle.
Why it’s conserved or increases:
- Geometry/Hamiltonian flow In lossless optics, rays move according to reversible laws. In ray phase space (position + direction), that flow preserves volume. Étendue is exactly that phase-space volume for a bundle of rays, so an ideal optical system cannot shrink it.
- You can trade area for angle, but not reduce both A lens can focus a large beam to a small spot, but then the angular spread increases. Or it can collimate a wide-angle source, but then the beam area grows. The product stays the same.
- Brightness cannot increase passively If étendue could decrease, you could make a passive optic that takes light from an extended source and makes it more radiance-dense than the source itself. That would mean increasing brightness without adding energy or work, which violates thermodynamic limits.
Why it can increase:
- scattering
- aberrations
- diffraction
- imperfect alignment
- partial obstruction or mixing
These processes scramble directions/positions and spread the beam in phase space, so étendue grows.
So the short answer is:
- Conserved in ideal, lossless, reversible optical systems because ray phase-space volume is preserved.
- Increases in real or non-ideal systems because irreversibility and wave effects spread the light out.
- Never decreases for passive optics, which is another way of stating conservation of radiance / second-law constraints.
If you want, I can also give:
- an intuitive lens example,
- the mathematical derivation from Liouville’s theorem,
- or the thermodynamics/brightness argument.
2. I want the mathematical derivation
For geometrical optics, étendue is the phase-space volume of a bundle of rays, and its conservation is just Liouville’s theorem in disguise.
2.0.1. 1. Define the ray phase space
A ray at some reference plane is specified by:
- transverse position \((x,y)\)
- direction, e.g. \((\theta_x,\theta_y)\) or direction cosines
For a medium of refractive index \(n\), the differential étendue is
\[ dG = n^2 \cos\theta \, dA\, d\Omega \]
where
- \(dA\) is an area element,
- \(d\Omega\) is a solid-angle element,
- \(\theta\) is angle to the surface normal.
In the paraxial limit,
\[ dG \approx n^2\, dx\,dy\, d\theta_x\, d\theta_y. \]
So étendue is essentially a 4D volume in ray phase space.
—
2.0.2. 2. Use canonical ray variables
In optics, rays follow Hamiltonian mechanics. A convenient canonical set is
\[ q_1=x,\quad q_2=y, \] \[ p_1=n\,u_x,\quad p_2=n\,u_y, \]
where \(\mathbf u\) is the unit direction vector of the ray.
Then the elementary phase-space volume is
\[ dq_1\,dq_2\,dp_1\,dp_2 = dx\,dy\,d(nu_x)\,d(nu_y). \]
Liouville’s theorem says that under Hamiltonian evolution,
\[ dx\,dy\,d(nu_x)\,d(nu_y) \]
is invariant.
That is the core mathematical statement behind étendue conservation.
—
2.0.3. 3. Relate this canonical volume to \(n^2 \cos\theta\, dA\, d\Omega\)
Let the direction be written as
\[ \mathbf u = (\sin\theta\cos\phi,\; \sin\theta\sin\phi,\; \cos\theta). \]
Then
\[ u_x = \sin\theta\cos\phi,\qquad u_y = \sin\theta\sin\phi. \]
We compute the Jacobian from angular coordinates \((\theta,\phi)\) to \((u_x,u_y)\):
\[ \frac{\partial(u_x,u_y)}{\partial(\theta,\phi)} =
\begin{vmatrix} \cos\theta\cos\phi & -\sin\theta\sin\phi\\ \cos\theta\sin\phi & \sin\theta\cos\phi \end{vmatrix}= cosθ\,sinθ. \]
Hence
\[ du_x\,du_y = \cos\theta\,\sin\theta\, d\theta\, d\phi. \]
But
\[ d\Omega = \sin\theta\, d\theta\, d\phi, \]
so
\[ du_x\,du_y = \cos\theta\, d\Omega. \]
Multiplying by \(n^2\),
\[ d(nu_x)\,d(nu_y) = n^2 \cos\theta\, d\Omega. \]
Therefore
\[ dx\,dy\,d(nu_x)\,d(nu_y) = n^2 \cos\theta\, dA\, d\Omega = dG. \]
So étendue is exactly the invariant phase-space measure.
—
2.0.4. 4. Why Hamiltonian flow preserves it
In geometrical optics, rays satisfy Hamilton’s equations:
\[ \dot q_i = \frac{\partial H}{\partial p_i},\qquad \dot p_i = -\frac{\partial H}{\partial q_i}. \]
The flow in phase space has zero divergence:
\[ ∑i \left( \frac{\partial \dot q_i}{\partial q_i}
\frac{\partial \dot p_i}{\partial p_i} \right) = ∑i \left( \frac{\partial^2 H}{\partial p_i \partial q_i}
\frac{\partial^2 H}{\partial q_i \partial p_i} \right) =0. \]
So the phase-space volume element is preserved. That is Liouville’s theorem.
Thus for any bundle of rays transported through an ideal optical system,
\[ G = \int n^2 \cos\theta\, dA\, d\Omega \]
is constant.
—
2.0.5. 5. Simple 1D paraxial version
In 1 transverse dimension, étendue reduces to
\[ dG \approx n\, dx\, d\theta. \]
Using \(p = n\theta\) in paraxial optics, this is just
\[ dG = dx\,dp. \]
A first-order optical system is represented by an ABCD matrix:
\[
\begin{pmatrix} x_2\\ p_2 \end{pmatrix}=
\begin{pmatrix} A & B\\ C & D \end{pmatrix}
\begin{pmatrix}
x1
p1
\end{pmatrix}.
\]
For a lossless optical system,
\[ AD-BC = 1. \]
The Jacobian determinant is therefore 1, so area in \((x,p)\) space is preserved:
\[ dx_2\,dp_2 = dx_1\,dp_1. \]
That is étendue conservation in the simplest form.
—
2.0.6. 6. Why it can increase but not decrease in practice
The derivation above assumes:
- geometric optics,
- lossless propagation,
- deterministic reversible ray mapping.
If you introduce scattering, absorption/re-emission, diffraction with truncation, or other irreversible processes, the mapping is no longer a clean one-to-one Hamiltonian flow for the occupied ray set. The occupied phase-space region can spread or mix, so effective étendue increases.
—
2.0.7. Final compact statement
Mathematically,
\[ dG = n^2 \cos\theta\, dA\, d\Omega \]
is conserved because it is the canonical phase-space volume element for ray optics:
\[ dG = dx\,dy\,dp_x\,dp_y, \]
and Hamiltonian evolution preserves phase-space volume by Liouville’s theorem.
If you want, I can next derive the optical Hamiltonian itself and show explicitly how Snell’s law and free-space propagation fit into this framework.